By Arslan Elahi, Snus O'Clock · Last updated 23 October 2026 · 6 min read
Fisherman's Friend lozenges all share the same famous menthol hit, but the three flavours we stock feel quite different. Original is the sharpest, Honey & Lemon is the smoothest and Blackcurrant puts fruit first. This guide compares them side by side so you can pick the right packet first time.
It follows on from our earlier Fisherman's Friend lozenges UK guide, which tells the story of the brand. Here we focus on one question: which flavour is right for you?

Quick answer
Quick answer
- Strongest menthol kick: Fisherman's Friend Original Menthol, with menthol and eucalyptus.
- Smoothest: Fisherman's Friend Honey & Lemon Menthol.
- Fruit first: Fisherman's Friend Blackcurrant Menthol.
- No nicotine: Fisherman's Friend lozenges are menthol lozenges, not nicotine products.
In this guide
The three flavours side by side

| Flavour | Main taste | Menthol feel | Sweetness | Sugar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original Menthol | Menthol and eucalyptus | Sharpest, most direct | Low | Check the packet |
| Honey & Lemon | Lemon with a soft honey note | Smoother, rounded | Medium | Sold as sugar-free in the UK |
| Blackcurrant | Rich, slightly tart blackcurrant | Cool finish after the fruit | Medium | Sold as sugar-free in the UK |
All three are slow-dissolving lozenges with a cooling menthol finish. The difference is how much flavour sits on top of that menthol, and how quickly the cool kicks in.
Original: the sharpest
Fisherman's Friend Original Menthol Lozenges are the classic. Menthol and eucalyptus come through straight away, with very little sweetness to soften them. If you search for "extra strong menthol lozenges", this is the one people mean. It is the best choice if you want the most intense cooling sensation, and the one to avoid if you prefer something mild.
Honey & Lemon: the smoothest
Fisherman's Friend Honey & Lemon Menthol Lozenges start with a bright lemon note, then a soft honey taste rounds it off before the menthol arrives. It feels warmer and less sharp than Original, which makes it the easiest Fisherman's Friend to try first.
Blackcurrant: fruit first
Fisherman's Friend Blackcurrant Menthol Lozenges lead with a deep, slightly tart blackcurrant flavour. The menthol follows as a cool finish rather than a sharp hit. Pick this if you want fruit and freshness in equal measure.
Which ones are sugar-free?
In the UK, Fisherman's Friend Honey & Lemon and Blackcurrant are sold as sugar-free lozenges, sweetened with sorbitol and other sweeteners. Packs carry a note that sorbitol can have a laxative effect if you eat too many. The classic Original is made in more than one version, so check the packet if sugar matters to you.
Ingredients can change, so always read the packet before you buy.
Which one should you pick?
- You want the strongest cooling hit: Original.
- You want something gentler: Honey & Lemon.
- You like fruit with your menthol: Blackcurrant.
- You avoid sugar: Honey & Lemon or Blackcurrant (check the packet).
- You cannot decide: try Original and Blackcurrant, and see which you reach for.
Browse all three in our Fisherman's Friend lozenges UK collection. They are an easy add-on to any order, and arrive with the rest of your parcel: order before 12 noon for next day UK delivery.
Fisherman's Friend is not a nicotine product

Because we sell nicotine pouches, customers sometimes ask if Fisherman's Friend contains nicotine. It does not. Here is how the three products differ:
| Fisherman's Friend | Nicotine lozenges | Nicotine pouches | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contains nicotine? | No | Yes | Yes |
| How you use it | Dissolve slowly in the mouth | Dissolve slowly in the mouth | Place under the top lip |
| Example we stock | Original Menthol | Nic Nac lozenges | Nicotine pouches |
| Age limit | Check the packet for age advice | 18+ | 18+ |
If you are looking for a nicotine lozenge, see our guide to Nic Nac nicotine lozenges. For pouches, start with nicotine pouches explained.
Related guides
Fisherman's Friend flavour FAQ
Which Fisherman's Friend flavour is the strongest?
Original Menthol is the strongest-tasting, with menthol and eucalyptus and very little sweetness. The fruit flavours have a softer menthol finish.
Which Fisherman's Friend flavour is the mildest?
Honey & Lemon is the smoothest of the three we stock. The honey and lemon round off the menthol, so it feels less sharp than Original.
What does Fisherman's Friend Original taste like?
Original tastes of strong menthol and eucalyptus with a direct cooling effect and little sweetness.
What does Fisherman's Friend Honey & Lemon taste like?
It opens with bright lemon, a soft honey note follows, and it finishes with a cool menthol taste.
What does Fisherman's Friend Blackcurrant taste like?
It has a rich, slightly tart blackcurrant flavour followed by a cooling menthol finish.
Which Fisherman's Friend flavour is the fruitiest?
Blackcurrant is the fruitiest of the three we stock. The blackcurrant comes first and the menthol follows as a cool finish.
Are Fisherman's Friend lozenges sugar-free?
In the UK, Honey & Lemon and Blackcurrant are sold as sugar-free lozenges sweetened with sorbitol. The Original comes in more than one version, so check the packet.
Can sugar-free Fisherman's Friend have side effects?
The sugar-free packs say they contain sorbitol, and that eating too many may have a laxative effect. Follow the advice on the packet.
Does Fisherman's Friend contain nicotine?
No. Fisherman's Friend lozenges are menthol lozenges and contain no nicotine.
Is Fisherman's Friend the same as a nicotine lozenge?
No. Nicotine lozenges, such as Nic Nac, contain nicotine. Fisherman's Friend lozenges do not.
Is Fisherman's Friend the same as snus or nicotine pouches?
No. Snus and nicotine pouches are placed under the lip and contain nicotine. Fisherman's Friend lozenges dissolve in the mouth and contain no nicotine.
How do you use a Fisherman's Friend lozenge?
Let one lozenge dissolve slowly in your mouth. Do not chew it or swallow it whole, and follow the directions on the packet.
Which Fisherman's Friend should I try first?
If you are new to the brand, start with Honey & Lemon for a smoother taste. If you want the classic strong menthol kick, start with Original.
Where can I buy Fisherman's Friend online in the UK?
You can buy Original, Honey & Lemon and Blackcurrant online at Snus O'Clock. Order before 12 noon for next day UK delivery.
Why does a nicotine pouch shop sell Fisherman's Friend?
Many of our customers love strong mint and menthol flavours, so Fisherman's Friend is a popular add-on to their order. It is a separate product and contains no nicotine.
Always read the packet for ingredients, directions and age advice. Fisherman's Friend lozenges contain no nicotine.